The Body and the Qi: Howard Choy’s Architectural Perspective
While Wu Xing deals with the intangible transformation of energy, the Form School (Luan Tou) deals with the tangible vessel that holds it. Architect and Feng Shui Master Howard Choy articulates a critical distinction in Classical Feng Shui: the relationship between Form (Xing) and Formula (Li Qi).
Choy posits that Form is the Body (Ti) and Formula is the Qi/Function (Yong) (Choy, 1998). This is a hierarchical relationship. Qi cannot exist without a form to contain it, just as water cannot be held without a cup. In the context of the built environment, the landscape acts as the container. Without a solid container, the "liquid" Qi disperses and is lost. Choy warns against the "Ghost" concept, where a mathematical formula is applied to a featureless landscape. A Flying Star chart might indicate wealth energy in a sector, but if that sector faces a solid brick wall (Form), there is no physical mechanism to activate that star (Choy, 1998).
The Four Celestial Animals: The Armchair Configuration The central diagnostic tool of the Form School is the model of the Four Celestial Animals (Si Shou). This model, derived from ancient astronomy, maps the ideal protective landscape for human habitation, representing the archetypal "Armchair" configuration (Skinner, 2019).
The Black Tortoise (Xuan Wu) – The Back: Ideally a high, strong mountain behind the site. It provides support and protection from harsh winds. In a modern context, it represents backing, mentorship, and health (Choy, 1998).
The Green Dragon (Qing Long) – The Left: A range of hills on the left, representing Yang energy and authority. It embraces the site to prevent Qi from leaking (Choy, 1998).
The White Tiger (Bai Hu) – The Right: A lower range of hills on the right, representing Yin energy. It must be lower than the Dragon to avoid "devouring" it, which would lead to conflict (Wong, 2001).
The Red Phoenix (Zhu Que) – The Front: A low mound or open space (Ming Tang) in front, often marked by water. It represents vision and the capacity to accumulate Qi (Skinner, 2019).
The Synergy of Form and Formula The interplay between Luan Tou (Form) and Li Qi (Formula) is the essence of professional Feng Shui practice. As Howard Choy suggests, reading the landscape is like reading a language. The landscape tells the story of the potential (the Body), while the compass formulas tell the story of the timing (the Qi) (Choy, 1998).
For instance, a "Wang Shan Wang Shui" (Prosperous Mountain, Prosperous Water) configuration only works if the form matches the formula: there must be a real mountain at the back to support the Mountain Star and real water at the front to activate the Water Star. If the forms are reversed, the "prosperous" chart becomes a disaster configuration. This confirms the hierarchy: Form prevails over Formula (Choy, 1998).
References
Choy, H. (1998). Feng Shui: Creating Health, Wealth and Harmony. Sydney: Pan Macmillan.
Lo, R. (2005). Feng Shui and Destiny. Hong Kong: Raymond Lo.
Skinner, S. (2019). Feng Shui History: The Story of Classical Feng Shui in China and the West from 221 BC to 2012 AD. London: Golden Hoard Press.
Wong, E. (2001). A Master Course in Feng-Shui: An In-Depth Program for Learning to Choose, Design, and Enhance the Spaces Where We Live and Work. Boston: Shambhala.