A Critical Historiography of the Bagua in Classical Chinese Metaphysics and

1. Introduction: The Ontological Schism in Feng Shui Practice

The transmission of Feng Shui from its dynastic origins in Imperial China to the industrialized West represents one of the most profound cross-cultural metamorphoses in the history of esotericism. Originally termed Kan Yu (the observation of the ways of Heaven and Earth), classical Feng Shui operated as a rigorous discipline of geomancy, inextricably bound to astronomy, geography, and the mathematical patterns of the I Ching (Book of Changes). It was a system predicated on the observation of objective environmental forces—magnetic fields, solar azimuths, and hydrological flows—to align human habitation with the dynamic pulse of the cosmos. However, the late 20th century witnessed the emergence of a syncretic variation known variously as Black Hat Sect Tantric Buddhist (BTB) Feng Shui, "Western Feng Shui," or the "Life Station" school. This adaptation, pioneered by Grandmaster Thomas Lin Yun, fundamentally altered the ontological basis of the practice, shifting the locus of power from the external, magnetic environment to the internal, psychological intent of the practitioner.

This article provides an exhaustive analysis into the historical origins of the Bagua in classical Chinese metaphysics, contrasting these foundational principles with the Western adaptations that have since permeated popular culture. It critically analyzes the creation of the BTB system, its divergence from classical principles like San He (Three Harmony) and San Yuan (Three Cycles), and the pivotal role of Thomas Lin Yun in this transformation. Furthermore, it evaluates the efficacy and theoretical validity of the fixed Bagua grid versus compass-based methods, synthesizing insights from classical masters such as Joseph Yu, Raymond Lo, Eva Wong and Stephen Skinner. The analysis reveals that the divergence is not merely methodological but epistemological: classical Feng Shui functions as an earth science of Qi distribution governed by time and direction, while BTB functions as a psycho-spiritual practice of spatial affirmation, effectively creating two distinct disciplines sharing a single name.

2. The Classical Origins of the Bagua: Cosmology and Calculation

To understand the magnitude of the Western adaptation, one must first excavate the archaeological and cosmological foundations of the Bagua itself. The Bagua (Eight Trigrams) serves as the fundamental lexicon of Chinese metaphysics, encoding the interactions of the cosmos into binary symbols. Its origins are shrouded in mythology yet grounded in the observational sciences of Neolithic China, long before the "aspirational" models of the West were conceived.

2.1 The Primordial Numerical Maps: He Tu and Luo Shu

Before the Bagua existed as a codified system of trigrams, Chinese cosmology relied on two numerical diagrams: the He Tu (River Map) and the Luo Shu (Luo River Scroll). These diagrams form the mathematical backbone of all classical Feng Shui formulas, including Xuan Kong Fei Xing (Flying Stars) and Ba Zhai (Eight Mansions), and their misinterpretation or omission is central to the critique of Western methods.

2.1.1 The He Tu: The Static Blueprint of Creation

The He Tu is attributed to the legendary sage Fu Xi (c. 3000 BCE), who allegedly observed the pattern on the flank of a dragon-horse emerging from the Yellow River. This diagram arranges numbers 1 through 10 in pairs, representing the perfect, static balance of the "Early Heaven" state. It establishes the "generative" and "consummative" relationship of the Five Elements (Wu Xing), which is critical for understanding why specific directions are associated with specific elements in classical theory:

• 1 and 6 (Water) reside in the North.

• 2 and 7 (Fire) reside in the South.

• 3 and 8 (Wood) reside in the East.

• 4 and 9 (Metal) reside in the West.

• 5 and 10 (Earth) reside in the Center.

This pairing provides the logic for "joining" or "combining" mountain and water dragons to create auspiciousness in the San He school. It represents the ideal, harmonious state of the universe before the manifestation of physical form and entropy.

2.1.2 The Luo Shu: The Dynamic Flux of Time

• The Luo Shu, associated with Yu the Great (c. 2100 BCE), depicts the dynamic, changing universe. Legend states it appeared on the shell of a giant tortoise from the River Luo. Unlike the static pairs of the He Tu, the Luo Shu numbers (1 through 9) are arranged in a magic square where every row, column, and diagonal sums to 15. This diagram represents the "Later Heaven" state—the world of gravity, time, and physical interaction.6

• Dynamic Qi Flow: The Luo Shu trajectory (5-6-7-8-9-1-2-3-4) defines the path of the "Nine Stars" (Purple White Stars) used in the Flying Star system to map the movement of energy over time. Master Joseph Yu emphasizes that this trajectory is essential for calculating the timeliness of energy; without it, Feng Shui becomes a static, dead art.

• Directional Association: The Luo Shu assigns numbers to magnetic directions: 1 (North), 9 (South), 3 (East), 7 (West), etc. This correlation forms the basis of the Compass School (Li Qi Pai), linking specific energies to magnetic azimuths measured by the Luo Pan.

2.2 The Dual Bagua Systems and the I Ching

The evolution of the Bagua from these numerical maps resulted in two distinct arrangements, each serving a specific metaphysical function. The conflation of these two arrangements is a common error in Western adaptations.

2.2.1 Early Heaven Bagua (Xian Tian)

Attributed to Fu Xi, this arrangement places opposing forces in perfect balance: Heaven (Qian) opposes Earth (Kun); Fire (Li) opposes Water (Kan). It represents the immutable laws of the universe and the cyclical nature of time (seasons, day/night). In classical Feng Shui, it is primarily used to analyze the "body" (Ti) of the environment—the inherent structure of the land and the relationships between water and mountain dragons. It is purely macrocosmic and does not dictate the flow of Qi inside a built structure in the same way the Later Heaven Bagua does.

2.2.2 Later Heaven Bagua (Hou Tian)

Attributed to King Wen of Zhou (c. 1050 BCE), this arrangement reflects the cyclical changes of life on earth: birth, growth, decay, and death. It correlates with the Five Elements, the seasons, and the magnetic directions. This is the operational tool for Yang House Feng Shui (residential analysis). It maps the flow of Qi across the eight compass sectors, assigning elemental qualities to magnetic directions (e.g., South is Fire/Li, North is Water/Kan). Crucially, this arrangement is dependent on magnetic orientation; it is not a psychological construct but a geomagnetic map.

3. The Genesis of the Black Hat Sect (BTB) System

The transition from classical geomancy to the "Black Hat" system represents a paradigm shift from objective orientation (compass) to subjective orientation (entryway). This shift was engineered by a single individual in the late 20th century, specifically tailored for a Western audience that lacked the cultural context for Chinese cosmology.

3.1 Thomas Lin Yun

Grandmaster Thomas Lin Yun (1932–2010), born in Beijing and later residing in Taiwan, introduced Feng Shui to the United States in the 1970s and 80s. Lin Yun founded the "Black Hat Sect Tantric Buddhist" (BTB) school, claiming lineage from the Tibetan Bon religion, Tantric Buddhism, and Chinese folklore. However, scholarly critiques and historical analysis suggest that his system was a modern synthesis designed for Western consumption rather than a direct transmission of ancient geomancy.

3.1.1 The "Fourth Stage" Synthesis

Lin Yun explicitly described his teaching as the "Fourth Stage" of Black Sect development. He claimed to incorporate "modern knowledge" such as psychology, physiology, architecture, and ecology into the traditional framework. This marked a deliberate departure from the rigid formulas of classical schools. Lin Yun recognized that Westerners would likely struggle with the complexities of the Luo Pan compass, Chinese calendars, and calculation-heavy methods like Flying Stars. He simplified the practice by prioritizing intention (Yi) and intuition over calculation. As noted by Joseph Yu, this school was designed to be "extremely easy to understand," stripping away the astronomical and geomagnetic requirements of the classical tradition.

3.2 The Invention of the "Three Door Gate" Method

The most radical innovation of the BTB system was the abolition of the magnetic compass. Lin Yun introduced the "Three Door" or "Triple Gate" method, which orients the Bagua solely based on the architectural entry of a room or building.

• The Relative "Mouth of Chi": In this system, the "Mouth of Chi" is defined as the front door. The Bagua grid is superimposed over the floor plan such that the entrance always aligns with the sectors of Knowledge (Gen), Career (Kan), or Helpful People (Qian).

• The Theory of Relative Positioning: This established the "Theory of Relative Positioning," positing that the energetic map of a space is determined by how one enters it, rather than its orientation to the earth's magnetic poles. This theory argues that the user's perception of the space defines its energy, a concept rooted in Western phenomenology rather than Chinese geomancy.

3.3 The Evangelist: Sarah Rossbach and the "Aspirations"

While Lin Yun was the architect, Sarah Rossbach was the evangelist who codified the system for the American market. Her 1983 book, Feng Shui: The Chinese Art of Placement, translated Lin Yun’s teachings into accessible English. Rossbach’s work stripped away much of the esoteric Buddhist ritual, presenting the "Life Aspirations" Bagua as a tool for interior design and self-help. It was through Rossbach’s publications that terms like "Wealth Corner" and "Relationship Corner" became ubiquitous in Western culture, effectively displacing the classical terminology of "Sheng Qi" or "Yan Nian" in the public consciousness.

4. Deconstructing the "Eight Aspirations": A Linguistic and Metaphysical Shift

The "Eight Aspirations" or "Life Stations" model used in BTB is not a direct translation of classical trigram attributes but a psychological reinterpretation. This section critically analyzes how classical meanings—rooted in familial and elemental archetypes—were morphed into modern socioeconomic aspirations.

4.1 Comparative Analysis of Trigram Attributes

The following table contrasts the classical attributes (derived from the I Ching and the 8 House School as taught by Joseph Yu) with the BTB "Life Aspirations" popularized by Lin Yun and Rossbach.

Kan (☵)

• Direction: North

• Element: Water

• Classical Attributes: Second Son, Danger, Abyss, Toil, Ear.

• BTB Aspiration: Career / Life Path

• The Shift: The classical idea of "flow" and the "abyss" (representing struggle or toil) was reinterpreted as the "path" of one's career. The element of danger was sanitized into a "life journey."

Gen (☶)

• Direction: Northeast

• Element: Earth

• Classical Attributes: Youngest Son, Stillness, Stopping, Hand.

• BTB Aspiration: Knowledge / Self-Cultivation

• The Shift: The attribute of "Stillness" and "stopping" (essential for meditation) was extrapolated into "contemplation," and subsequently, "knowledge."

Zhen (☳)

• Direction: East

• Element: Wood

• Classical Attributes: Eldest Son, Arousing, Movement, Feet.

• BTB Aspiration: Family / New Beginnings

• The Shift: The "Eldest Son" represents the family line or heir in Confucian thought. The "Arousing" attribute was translated into "New Beginnings" (associated with Spring).

Xun (☴)

• Direction: Southeast

• Element: Wood

• Classical Attributes: Eldest Daughter, Penetrating, Gentle, Thighs.

• BTB Aspiration: Wealth / Prosperity

• The Shift: A major divergence. Classical "Wind" implies dispersion, not accumulation. BTB likely links this to the Wood element (growth) and perhaps the 8 House "Sheng Qi" (Life Generating) energy, though Sheng Qi is directional, not fixed to the Southeast.

Li (☲)

• Direction: South

• Element: Fire

• Classical Attributes: Second Daughter, Clinging, Brightness, Eye.

• BTB Aspiration: Fame / Reputation

• The Shift: "Brightness" and "Visibility" translate logically to "Fame." This is the most consistent overlap between the two systems.

Kun (☷)

• Direction: Southwest

• Element: Earth

• Classical Attributes: Mother, Receptive, Belly, Cloth.

• BTB Aspiration: Love / Relationships

• The Shift: The "Mother" and "Receptive" qualities were mapped onto "Partnership" and "Marriage," shifting the focus from matriarchy to romance.

Dui (☱)

• Direction: West

• Element: Metal

• Classical Attributes: Youngest Daughter, Joy, Mouth, Sheep.

• BTB Aspiration: Children / Creativity

• The Shift: The "Youngest Daughter" and "Joy" attributes link naturally to children. The Metal element links to precision and creativity.

Qian (☰)

• Direction: Northwest

• Element: Metal

• Classical Attributes: Father, Creative, Head, King.

• BTB Aspiration: Helpful People / Travel

• The Shift: The "King/Father" archetype represents authority and benevolence, which was morphed into the concept of "Benefactors" or "Helpful People."

4.2 The "Wealth Corner" Fallacy

In classical Feng Shui, wealth is governed by the Water Star (in Flying Stars) or the Sheng Qi sector (in 8 Mansions). Neither of these is fixed to the Southeast.

• Flying Stars Logic: The wealth spot moves with time. In Period 7 (1984–2004), the wealth star was #7; in Period 8 (2004–2024), it was #8. A house could have its "Wealth Star" in the North, South, or any direction depending on the chart.7

• BTB Distortion: By fixing "Wealth" to the rear-left corner (Southeast in the ideal grid), BTB created a static "Wealth Corner" accessible to everyone regardless of their house's actual energy map. This democratization of Feng Shui sacrificed accuracy for marketability.24 Raymond Lo specifically critiques this, noting that placing a water feature in the Southeast could bring disaster if the Flying Star chart for that house locates a "Five Yellow" or "Argumentative 3" star in that sector.

5. Critical Analysis: Fixed Bagua Grid vs. Compass-Based Methods

The divergence between the fixed Bagua grid and compass-based methods represents the core conflict between "New Age" and "Classical" Feng Shui. This section synthesizes the critiques from classical masters regarding the implications of abandoning the compass.

5.1 The Fixed Grid (BTB): Psychology Over Geomancy

Methodology: Align the bottom of the grid with the wall containing the front door.

• Pros: Highly accessible; requires no tools; focuses on psychological intent; empowers the user to "take action" immediately.

• Cons: Ignores the physical environment; assumes all houses function energetically identical regardless of orientation; completely disregards the magnetic field, which classical practitioners argue is the medium of Qi.

• Theoretical Flaw: As noted by critics, if a house faces North and another faces South, their exposure to solar radiation, wind patterns, and magnetic fields is diametrically opposed. Treating them as identical because the "door is the bottom of the map" logically disconnects the practice from the physical reality of the planet.

5.2 Compass-Based Methods (San Yuan / San He): The Earth Science

Methodology: Use a Luo Pan to measure the precise magnetic facing (down to the degree).

• San He (Forms): Analyzes the landscape (mountains/water) relative to the 24 Mountains ring. This school emphasizes that the "Dragons" (mountain ranges) and "Water" (rivers/roads) carry specific Qi that must be captured by the correct orientation.

• San Yuan (Time): Analyzes the "Flying Stars" based on the construction date and magnetic facing. This system acknowledges that Qi is dynamic and cyclical. As explained by Joseph Yu, "Time is what we call Heaven Luck. If you are born at the right moment, your life will be easy... The same house may be fortunate in a certain period of time and unfortunate in the next decade".

• Pros: Diagnoses the unique energetic blueprint of the specific structure; accounts for time (changing luck periods); aligns with the "Heaven Luck" (Time) and "Earth Luck" (Direction) variables.

• Cons: Complex; requires training; diagnostic results can be negative (e.g., "this house is bad for wealth"), which is less marketable than BTB's "enhance your wealth corner" approach.

5.3 Joseph Yu’s Critique: The "Life Station Cult"

Master Joseph Yu, a proponent of classical Feng Shui, offers a scathing critique of the "Life Station" school in his course materials. He identifies it as a "new 'school of Feng Shui'" invented in the 70s by "one clever man" (an allusion to Lin Yun).

• "Pseudo-Feng Shui": Yu explicitly categorizes these schools as "Pseudo-Feng Shui" because they deviate from the fundamental definition of Feng Shui as an environmental study of time and space. He argues that the "Life Station" theory is a "cheap imitation" of the Ba Gua because it strips the trigrams of their dynamic, cosmological context and reduces them to static, aspirational zones.

• The Principle of Harmony: Yu asserts that "If a Feng Shui practitioner deviates from creating an environment in harmony with Nature, he is not a genuine Feng Shui Master." He contrasts the "Life Station" school's focus on internal aspirations with the classical goal of aligning with external "Earth Luck".

5.4 Stephen Skinner’s Critique: "McFengShui" and the Loss of Directions

Stephen Skinner, a renowned scholar of Western and Chinese esotericism, provides a historical critique of the BTB method, often referring to it as "McFengShui"—a commodified, simplified version of the art designed for mass consumption rather than effective results.

• Astronomy without a Telescope: Skinner argues that removing the compass from Feng Shui is akin to "astronomy without a telescope." He emphasizes that Feng Shui is a form of geomancy—an earth science—not merely a psychological exercise. By ignoring the cardinal directions, BTB practitioners sever the link between the house and the terrestrial magnetic field.

• Historical Fabrication: Skinner critiques the BTB method's reliance on the "mouth of chi" (door) as absolute North as a fabrication with no basis in the classical texts (e.g., Qing Nang Jing or Zang Shu). He notes that classical texts always reference the 24 Mountains and the magnetic poles, never a relative door position.

5.5 Raymond Lo’s Critique: Science vs. Superstition

Grandmaster Raymond Lo ("Feng Shui Lo") emphasizes the "scientific" aspect of classical Feng Shui, framing it as a study of energy calculations rather than spiritual intuition.

• The Necessity of Calculation: Lo argues that Feng Shui is about "calculating" the influence of the environment. Without the compass (Luo Pan) and the time factor (Flying Stars), one cannot calculate anything. He views the fixed bagua as a "New Age" invention that conflates positive thinking with energetic manipulation. While positive thinking has value, Lo maintains it is distinct from the mechanics of Qi.

• Destiny vs. Environment: Lo distinguishes between "Heaven Luck" (Destiny/BaZi), which is inborn, and "Earth Luck" (Feng Shui), which is environmental. He critiques BTB for blurring these lines, attempting to use environmental placebos to fix destiny issues without addressing the actual energetic blueprint of the home.

6. Detailed Case Study: The Divergence in Application

To illustrate the practical difference between these systems, consider a hypothetical house built in Period 8 (2004–2024) facing South 2 (180°).

6.1 BTB Assessment (The "Three Door" Method)

• Orientation: The practitioner stands at the front door (South). The door is the "Mouth of Chi."

• Map Alignment: The door aligns with the "Career" sector (Kan). Consequently, the rear left corner (Southeast) is designated as the "Wealth" sector, and the rear right (Southwest) is the "Relationships" sector.

• Recommendation: Place a water fountain in the Southeast (Wealth) to stimulate money luck and pink crystals in the Southwest (Love) to enhance relationships.

• 6.2 Classical Flying Star Assessment (San Yuan)

• Orientation: The house faces South 2. Using the Luo Pan, the practitioner identifies the specific 15-degree sector (Wu).

• Chart Analysis: The chart for a Period 8 South 2 facing house is a Double 8 at the Sitting (Mountain Star 8 and Water Star 8 are both in the North/Sitting palace).

• Wealth Analysis: The timely Water Star #8 (the true Wealth Star for Period 8) is trapped in the back of the house (North), not the front or Southeast. The Southeast sector contains the #4 and #1 stars (Romance/Academic), not necessarily wealth.

• The Danger of the BTB Cure: More critically, if the Southeast contained the #2 (Sickness) or #5 (Yellow) stars—which shift annually or in different 20-year periods—the BTB recommendation to place a fountain (active water) in the Southeast would energetically activate these malicious stars, potentially causing illness or financial disaster.

• Conclusion: The BTB "Wealth Corner" does not exist in the classical chart. The energy map is specific to the building's orientation and construction date, not the door's relative position. The classical cure would involve activating the North sector (where the #8 Water Star resides) to unlock the house's wealth potential, a strategy completely missed by the BTB map.

7. The Role of Time: Flying Stars vs. Static Sectors

A critical divergence point highlighted by Joseph Yu and Raymond Lo is the treatment of time.

7.1 The Classical View: Energy is Cyclical

Classical Feng Shui, particularly the Flying Star school, is predicated on the concept that Qi is dynamic.

• The 9 Periods: Time is divided into 20-year cycles. A house built in Period 7 (1984–2003) has a different chart than one built in Period 8 (2004–2023). The "ruling star" changes, altering the auspiciousness of every sector.

• Annual Afflictions: Classical practitioners also account for annual stars. For example, the "Five Yellow" star moves every year. If it lands in the "Wealth Corner" defined by BTB, activating that corner could be catastrophic.

• Yu's Insight: Yu notes that "studying Feng Shui without referring to the time factor is assuming the world does not change over time. This is not logical".

7.2 The BTB View: Energy is Static

The BTB system treats the Bagua sectors as static aspirational zones. The "Wealth Area" is always the rear left, regardless of the year, the building's age, or the planetary alignment. This simplifies the practice but removes the dimension of time, which classical masters argue is essential for accurate prediction and remediation.

8. Conclusion: Two Disciplines, One Name

The "Bagua" as understood in the West is a distinct artifact from the Bagua of classical Chinese metaphysics. The classical Bagua is a cosmological compass, a tool for mapping the objective, invisible magnetic forces (Qi) that permeate the environment. It is rigorous, mathematical, and inextricably linked to the physical orientation of the earth and the temporal cycles of the solar system.

The BTB Bagua, created by Thomas Lin Yun, is a psycho-spiritual map. It is a tool for mapping human intention onto a space. By severing the link to the compass and the calendar, Lin Yun democratized Feng Shui, making it accessible to a Western audience hungry for spiritual control over their environment. However, in doing so, he fundamentally altered the mechanism of the practice.

As the research indicates, the BTB system's "Eight Aspirations" are modern reinterpretations—metaphors draped over ancient symbols. The "Career" sector is not the "Kan" trigram of the I Ching; it is a modern concept grafted onto an ancient archetype. For the classical purist (like Yu, Skinner, or Lo), this renders BTB a "pseudo-science," a practice that mimics the aesthetics of Feng Shui without engaging its underlying mechanics. Yet, for the millions of Western practitioners, the psychological efficacy of the "Life Stations" provides a tangible sense of agency, suggesting that while the geomancy may be absent, the magic—in the psychological sense of intent and affirmation—remains potent.

The divergence is stark: one system asks the occupant to align with the unyielding forces of nature (Earth Luck), while the other asks nature to align with the psychological desires of the occupant (Human Luck). Understanding this distinction is the only way to navigate the complex, often contradictory landscape of modern Feng Shui.

Divergence of Trigram Interpretations: Classical vs. BTB

North (Water)

• Classical Element: Water

• Classical Archetype: Middle Son / Danger

• BTB Aspiration: Career

• Basis of Divergence: Water's "flow" reinterpreted as life path.

Southwest (Earth)

• Classical Element: Earth

• Classical Archetype: Mother / Receptive

• BTB Aspiration: Relationships

• Basis of Divergence: Mother/Nurturing reinterpreted as romantic partnership.

East (Wood)

• Classical Element: Wood

• Classical Archetype: Eldest Son / Thunder

• BTB Aspiration: Family / Health

• Basis of Divergence: "Growth" of wood linked to family lineage.

Southeast (Wood)

• Classical Element: Wood

• Classical Archetype: Eldest Daughter / Wind

• BTB Aspiration: Wealth

• Basis of Divergence: Wind/Penetration reinterpreted as "accumulation" (growth).

Northwest (Metal)

• Classical Element: Metal

• Classical Archetype: Father / Heaven

• BTB Aspiration: Helpful People

• Basis of Divergence: "Heaven/King" reinterpreted as benefactors/mentors.

West (Metal)

• Classical Element: Metal

• Classical Archetype: Youngest Daughter / Joy

• BTB Aspiration: Children / Creativity

• Basis of Divergence: "Joy" and "Offspring" linked to creativity.

Northeast (Earth)

• Classical Element: Earth

• Classical Archetype: Youngest Son / Mountain

• BTB Aspiration: Knowledge

• Basis of Divergence: "Stillness" of mountain linked to meditation/study.

South (Fire)

• Classical Element: Fire

• Classical Archetype: Middle Daughter / Fire

• BTB Aspiration: Fame

• Basis of Divergence: "Brightness" directly linked to visibility/reputation.

(Note: While the classical archetypes are rooted in the I Ching's familial and elemental attributes, the BTB aspirations impose modern sociological goals onto these ancient frameworks.)

References:

• Level 1 Fundamentals, Joseph Yu, Feng Shui Research Centre

• Feng Shui Books - Dr. Stephen Skinner https://www.sskinner.com/books.htm

• Stephen Skinner, Guide to the Feng Shui Compass - CORE, https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/228877453.pdf

• Advanced Flying Star Feng Shui - The Golden Hoard Press, https://www.goldenhoard.net/fengshui.htm

• Stephen Skinner, What you didn't know about Eight Mansion Feng Shui - YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l74Ypduu00o

• FINDING MY RELIGION / Writer Stephen Skinner talks about sacred geometry, nature's blueprints and the fine art of feng shui - SFGATE, https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/FINDING-MY-RELIGION-Writer-Stephen-Skinner-2606913.php

• Feng shui revisited with Grand Master Raymond Lo - Gulf News, https://gulfnews.com/lifestyle/health-fitness/feng-shui-revisited-with-grand-master-raymond-lo-1.1049963

• Feng Shui Master Raymond Lo, https://raymond-lo.com/p/14534/nr/100038/feng-shui-master-raymond-lo

• Feng Shui Evaluation - Raymond Lo, http://raymond-lo.com/14528/feng-shui-evaluation

• Ernst Johann Eitel: A Nineteenth-Century Appraisal of Feng Shui - ResearchGate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334555184_Ernst_Johann_Eitel_A_Nineteenth-Century_Appraisal_of_Feng_Shui

• Bagua Definition, Significance & Uses - Study.com https://study.com/academy/lesson/bagua-overview-map-facts-symbol.html

• Bagua - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bagua

• Feng Shui Technical Aspects, https://michaeloon.com/blog/feng-shui-technical-aspects/

• Bagua Feng Shui Map Usages & Applications | - Dougles Chan, https://dougleschan.com/bagua/bagua-feng-shui-map-usages-applications%EF%BF%BC/

• Decoding Early Heaven and Later Heaven Bagua - Imperial Harvest, https://imperialharvest.com/blog/early-heaven-and-later-heaven-bagua/

• Bagua, Early Heaven Sequence, Later Heaven sequence - Chinese Customs - Nationsonline.org, https://www.nationsonline.org/oneworld/Chinese_Customs/bagua.htm

• Feng shui | Meaning, Definition, Facts, & Chinese Religion | Britannica, https://www.britannica.com/art/fengshui

• Introduction - Yun Lin Temple, https://www.yunlintemple.org/introduction

• What is BTB Feng Shui? - Feng Shui Designs, Inc, https://fengshuidesigns.com/btb-feng-shui/

• Feng Shui 101: An Introduction to the Bagua, https://morrisfengshui.com/blog/bagua-intro

• Feng Shui: The Chinese Art of Placement - Sarah Rossbach - Google Books, https://books.google.com/books/about/Feng_Shui.html?id=F0JjAAAACAAJ

• Interior Design with Feng Shui by Sarah Rossbach: 9780140196085 | PenguinRandomHouse.com: Books, https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/350857/interior-design-with-feng-shui-by-sarah-rossbach/

• 8 Powerful Life Enhancements Using The Feng Shui Life Aspirations Formula., https://michaeloon.com/blog/feng-shui-life-aspirations-formula/

• The East-West System is a Compass School Feng Shui – Part II - Asian Lifestyle Design, https://asianlifestyledesign.com/2010/05/the-east-west-system-is-a-compass-school-feng-shui-part-ii/

• The Black Sect | Feng Shui Your Life, https://fengshui.com.au/about-feng-shui/schools-of-feng-shui/the-black-sect/

• Feng Shui | January 20, 2012 | Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly - PBS, https://www.pbs.org/wnet/religionandethics/2012/01/20/january-20-2012-feng-shui/10118/